It’s meme time. Let’s get Berned.
The Bernie Sanders chair memes have been the best of 2021 so far. They are based on a photo of Senator Sanders sitting socially distanced in public and being his modest with a pair of brown mittens that the Internet is going crazy about.
The Internet is truly amazing –
*below uses are for educational purposes only
After hours of laughing, I decided to be a nerd and analyze the rights associated in the Bernie Sanders chair memes. In short, a meme is usually a derivative work that involves copyright and, on occasions, persons’ right to privacy.
It all began with an original photo taken by photographer Brendan Smialowski (in other cases, a meme could start with an original image made by a creator / illustrator). The original Bernie Sanders chair photo was credited as Brendan Smialowski/AFP/Getty Images. It looks like Smialowski is a correspondent works for AFP, the major French news agency. Most likely, the original photo is a work made for hire under the definition of copyright law and AFP is the copyright owner to the original image. Getty Images, on the other hand, is the licensing agent for the original photo.
In this case, Sen. Sanders will not be able to claim the right to privacy (including the right to his name and likeness) in these memes because he is a public official and the photo was taken in public. Usually, anyone could fairly use an image of a person if the photo of the person is taken in a space where a reasonable person would not expect privacy, or if the photo is newsworthy and concerning a public official or public figure. AFP, the copyright owner, is therefore allowed to use Sen. Sanders’ image in the news articles without an invasion to Sen. Sanders’ privacy.
During the 2021 inauguration, people started to create brilliant memes using this AFP image. These memes hardly infringe AFP’s copyright because of the doctrine of fair use in copyright law. In short, a meme is a “parody” where the creator is permitted to fairly use others’ material to make fun of, as long as the use is fair and necessary.
How about the rights by meme creators? If you make a Bernie Sanders meme today, do you own it? The answer is - you may own part of it if you use some of your original elements. However, the original copyright owner is entitled to all of the derivative works, which would technically include the meme that you create, as long as the meme features predominately the original content, i.e., Sen. Sanders and his mittens.
It’s worth mentioning that you may actually infringe others’ copyright when creating memes. Once, there was a famous “Socially Awkward Penguin” meme that went viral. Not known to many meme creators, the penguin image is copyrighted and is owned by National Geographic, who launched copyright enforcement proceedings against “infringers”. Unlike the Bernie Sanders chair meme, the use of a copyrighted penguin there was not parody, because, in my opinion, it didn’t have to be this penguin, so the use was unnecessary and unfair. Watch out what images you are using :).
Lastly, here’s my favorite Bernie Sanders chair meme –
Silvia Sun, Esq.
Copyright© 2021, Xiaoyun Sun. All rights reserved.
Any reproduction of any content of this site is prohibited other than reproductions for individual, non-commercial, and informational use. This limited permission to recopy does not allow you to modify or incorporate any portion of the contents in any work or publication regardless of the medium. You may not recopy and share reproductions with a third party.
*Disclaimers: Silvia Legal Discoveries content is provided for informational purposes only; it is not legal advice and may not be relied upon as such. Silvia Xiaoyun Sun makes no representations as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity of any information on Silvia Legal Discoveries and will not be liable for any errors or omissions in them for delays in publication of information, or for any losses, injuries, or damages arising from the display or use for any other reason whatsoever. No endorsement of any product or service mentioned on Silvia Legal Discoveries is expressed or implied. All information is provided on an as-is basis. Linked resources are beyond the control of Silvia Legal Discoveries, and Silvia Legal Discoveries shall have no responsibility whatsoever for the acts or omissions of such third parties. Comments are solely the work of their authors and as such do not necessarily reflect the views of Silvia Legal Discoveries or Silvia Xiaoyun Sun. Neither the use of content provided on Silvia Legal Discoveries blog nor the submission of any information through Silvia Legal Discoveries blog creates an attorney-client relationship between you and Silvia Xiaoyun Sun. Please be aware that any information that you provide through Silvia Legal Discoveries is not secure and it is not privileged or confidential. In fact, by posting you intend that your comment be displayed so that others can read it and comment on it. Silvia Legal Discoveries reserves the right to edit submissions for any reason in its sole discretion.